Job interview details: Justify hiring DPD/WC witness Whaley or Virginia Davis

[John Mytton]

That would mean we can?t take the testimony of anyone. I don?t think Diogenes ever found a single person who matched his search criteria.
Most everyone has something they will lie about. Lying about one?s age is natural, if one was married at an age many would consider too young.
It is impossible to name a single JFK witness who has never told a lie without telling a lie.

 

Exactly, it's like these CT's have never lived in the real World. And show me a women who doesn't lie about her age, when they're young they want to be old and when they're old they want to be young.

JohnM

[Richard Smith]

Unbelievable what alternate universe do you live in?

By your standard there is no testimony anywhere that can ever be deemed to be accurate because like it or not after Jesus every single one of us has lied and you more than most.

JohnM

Yes, the notion that Dishonest John, the single biggest liar on this forum, would call out a teenage girl for indicating that she was 16 instead of 15 and a few months old is rich irony.  And imagine some war veteran exaggerating his war record.  I bet that has never happened in history.  Obviously he can't be trusted to confirm that Oswald took a ride in his cab.  All sinister lies but no one is suggesting a strawman conspiracy that would require some proof or at least an explanation.   Just random citizens lying for no reason.

[Howard Gee]

What ?  So you don't believe Whaley and Davis were part of the conspiracy to frame poor Saint Patsy ? What's wrong with you ?

    

[John Mytton]

Yes, the notion that Dishonest John, the single biggest liar on this forum, would call out a teenage girl for indicating that she was 16 instead of 15 and a few months old is rich irony.  And imagine some war veteran exaggerating his war record.  I bet that has never happened in history.  Obviously he can't be trusted to confirm that Oswald took a ride in his cab.  All sinister lies but no one is suggesting a strawman conspiracy that would require some proof or at least an explanation.   Just random citizens lying for no reason.

Obviously he can't be trusted to confirm that Oswald took a ride in his cab.

This is another pointless exercise they accuse Whaley of lying or whatever, yet according to at least two of Oswald's interrogators, Oswald openly admitted that he caught a cab and Whaley's manifest says he went to the same street that Oswald lived on at about the same time that his housekeeper saw Oswald.

JohnM

[John Iacoletti]

That would mean we can?t take the testimony of anyone. I don?t think Diogenes ever found a single person who matched his search criteria.
Most everyone has something they will lie about. Lying about one?s age is natural, if one was married at an age many would consider too young.
It is impossible to name a single JFK witness who has never told a lie without telling a lie.

That puts you in quite a bind given that your case relies on witness testimony, in most cases uncorroborated witness testimony.

[John Iacoletti]

Yes, the notion that Dishonest John, the single biggest liar on this forum,

You still haven't cited a single lie.  Nor will you ever.

would call out a teenage girl for indicating that she was 16 instead of 15 and a few months old is rich irony.  And imagine some war veteran exaggerating his war record.  I bet that has never happened in history.

So basically you know when people's testimony is accurate and reliable and when it isn't, because.....reasons.  How utterly self-serving.

[John Iacoletti]

This is another pointless exercise they accuse Whaley of lying or whatever, yet according to at least two of Oswald's interrogators, Oswald openly admitted that he caught a cab and Whaley's manifest says he went to the same street that Oswald lived on at about the same time that his housekeeper saw Oswald.

"about the same time".  LOL.

[John Mytton]

"about the same time".  LOL.

Whaley said his time schedule wasn't exact and Roberts said about 1PM so yeah about the same time. Anyway it's all immaterial anyway because Oswald admitted catching a bus and a cab, this can go no further, it ceases to be.

JohnM