Howard Brennan showed DPD which window the shots had come from

[John Iacoletti]

It was probably the rifle.. but by all means, feel free to suggest what else the 'something narrow' could have been.

Shifting the burden of proof again?  Why was it "probably" a rifle (much less THE rifle)?

[John Iacoletti]

In JAQer/CTer wonderland, 'if I want to believe there was no rifle, then there was no rifle'

Belief has nothing to do with it.  What can be proven with evidence, rather than an arbitrary and capricious declaration of probability?

[Bill Chapman]

Shifting the burden of proof again?  Why was it "probably" a rifle (much less THE rifle)?

 

A rifle was seen in that window
Or did Euins/Brennan imagine it

[John Iacoletti]

A rifle was seen in that window
Or did Euins/Brennan imagine it

Euins is the one who called it "pipe thing".  Brennan claimed to see all kinds of details.

[John Iacoletti]

By the way, describe the people looking out the 7th floor window.  Yes, there are people looking out the 7th floor window.

[Bill Chapman]

Belief has nothing to do with it.  What can be proven with evidence, rather than an arbitrary and capricious declaration of probability?

If it shoots like a rifle it must be a rifle

Brennan said the gunman, after the final shot, stepped away from the window with the rifle
Jackson et al looked up too late to as much as what Brennan saw

BFD to JAQers/CTers huh..

[Walt Cakebread]

If it shoots like a rifle it must be a rifle

Brennan said the gunman, after the final shot, stepped away from the window with the rifle
Jackson et al looked up too late to as much as what Brennan saw

BFD to JAQers/CTers huh..

Brennan said the gunman, after the final shot, stepped away from the window with the rifle

Excellent point Mr Crapman....  Now please explain to the folks HOW a gunman could step away from the window with the barricade boxes stacked behind him?   

So not only would the barricade have squeezed a man STANDING behind that window and prevented him from aiming a rifle down onto Elm street, that barricade would also have prevented him from stepping back away from that window.  Thank you for presenting the proof that the gunman was NOT behind that SE corner window.... 

[Richard Smith]

In JAQer/CTer wonderland, it couldashouldawoulda been a curtain-rod 'something narrow' sticking out that window. Or maybe a yardstick.

Using Dishonest John's form of mislogic, no one saw John Wilkes Booth shoot Lincoln.  They heard a bang, looked in that direction, and saw him holding a smoking object made of "wood" pointing at Lincoln's head.  You can't make that kind of nonsense up.  Jackson pointed out the "rifle" and another person saw it.  A search found bullet casings by that window.   John doesn't even believe his own nonsense.  It's Alice-in-Wonderland defense attorney bull.  Just playing the lazy contrarian again.