Common Ground?

[Duncan MacRae]

Repeatedly saying the cylinder has an inside, doesn't prove that it has a side (or face ) inside.

If you inject a solid object with another smaller object and seal the injection point of entry, then, in order to escape from the inside of the solid object, the injected object would be required to pierce any point where the injected object touches the inside of any outer edge, ie, the inner side. 

[Ray Mitcham]

Not weally, Dennis, I'm just vewy cwever.

Let's put it slightly differently.  Every Scotsman has a face on the outside of his head. With your reasoning, he also has a face on the inside,  proving that all Scotsman are two faced. I'll settle for that argument over.

Q.E.D.

[Duncan MacRae]

Let's put it slightly differently.  Every Scotsman has a face on the outside of his head. With your reasoning, he also has a face on the inside,  proving that all Scotsman are two faced. I'll settle for that argument over.

Q.E.D.

Thanks for conceding, Ray. I admire your honesty. 

[Jack Trojan]

What if you have a cylinder that is 1 atom thick?

[Duncan MacRae]

What if you have a cylinder that is 1 atom thick?

Ray's the only one who can answer that, he's the Forum's expert on anything thick. 

[Ray Mitcham]

Thanks for conceding, Ray. I admire your honesty. 

What makes you think I have conceded? But glad to see  you accept my conclusion. Just pointing out the illogicality of your argument.

[Anthony Clayden]

What hope of solving the puzzles in this case, if we can't agree on the sides of a cylinder.

[Rob Caprio]

I would say that we all agree that JFK was killed.  But that's not even true.  Patrick Jackson who used to post here had a narrative that involved JFK faking his death.

He's not alone John as there are some who think that JFK lived and he became Jimmy Carter!