Tippit Shooting, 1:15

[John Iacoletti]

Benavides (on second thought, it seems) gave Oswald the benefit of the doubt, since he didn't know the name of guy with the gun at the time.

At the time of his testimony? 

The hits just keep coming!

[John Iacoletti]

First of all Benavides goes on to say he identified Oswald from the pictures of Oswald that he saw,

No, he said he “figured” it was Oswald”, whatever that means. On 11/22, he said he didn’t think he could identify him.

[Walt Cakebread]

First of all Benavides goes on to say he identified Oswald from the pictures of Oswald that he saw, so stop with this insane cherry picking and beside how would Benavides know whose real name the murderer was, Oswald also went by O'H Lee and Alek Hidell. And btw the singular "Oswald" doesn't really define Lee Harvey Oswald, the name Oswald applied to perhaps hundreds or even thousands of people across America.

Mr. BELIN - You used the name Oswald. How did you know this man was Oswald?
Mr. BENAVIDES - From the pictures I had seen. It looked like a guy, resembled the guy. That was the reason I figured it was Oswald.

JohnM

how would Benavides know whose real name the murderer was, \
Huh?   Nobody has suggested that Benavides knew the name of the killer.....  Benavides  simply said "OR the guy that shot him," which means he knew the guy was not Lee Oswald......

[John Iacoletti]

At a minimum it indicates that Benavides wasn’t certain about who it was.

Some “identification”.

[Bill Chapman]

When did I say I wanted to change anybody’s mind? In fact, I said the exact opposite. You’re just not very good at this, are you?

Stop squirming... and why do you attempt, for instance, to push your atheism down people's throats if you don't want to change people's minds? You have the same attitude here.

You said:
"Exactly. You’re not ever going to change their minds, but you’re exposing their fallacies for everybody else who’s watching".

[Walt Cakebread]

At a minimum it indicates that Benavides wasn’t certain about who it was.

Some “identification”.

At a minimum it indicates that Benavides wasn’t certain about who it was.

IMO I think Benavides is saying, " I know that popular belief, and the news media,  says that the man was Oswald, but I saw the man face to face, and he was not the man that I saw later that day on TV.   

 

[Bill Chapman]

At the time of his testimony? 
>>> in reference to his situation on scene at the time

The hits just keep coming!
>>> My condolences; you are definitely punch-drunk

[Bill Chapman]

No, Dummy..That's not right.    Benavides said OR the guy that shot him, which means he knew the guy's name was NOT  Oswald.

 

Stop changing your tune. You've claimed an alternate shooter all along