Then went outside to watch P. parade ( Parts 1 & 2 )

[Alan Ford]

What is clear is that the mystery man is not a police officer. He can only be an employee of the TSBD. And not an office worker.
This leaves two realistic choices - it is either Lovelady on a box wearing different clothes or it's the very tall Jack Dougherty wearing his own clothes.

So, after all your huffing and puffing, you are now forced to accept that Mr. Lovelady standing on a box is indeed a realistic explanation?

Splendid. Your wild notion that 'mystery man' (~grin~) might be your accused assassin Mr. Dougherty can now be consigned to the trash can--------along with what little was left of your credibility as a student of the visual record.

 

[Dan O'meara]

So, after all your huffing and puffing, you are now forced to accept that Mr. Lovelady standing on a box is indeed a realistic explanation?

Splendid. Your wild notion that 'mystery man' (~grin~) might be your accused assassin Mr. Dougherty can now be consigned to the trash can--------along with what little was left of your credibility as a student of the visual record.

 

The Fantastical Mr Ford rides in on his unicorn again.
Your "Multi-racial Assassination Death Squad Roaming Around the TSBD Building" theory [MADS for short] is the product of a truly fevered imagination.
Only to be outdone by your "Oswald Rolling Out a Banner" theory.
But none are as ridiculous as your "Prayer Man" theory.
What a joke that was. Glad to see you woke up from that nightmare but, oh, those wasted years.

And what about my crazy "Mystery Man" theory.
An really tall, unidentified TSBD employee appears in Alyea's film. Only Jack Dougherty fits that bill.
The film is taken in the immediate aftermath of the rifle's discovery, before Day has picked it up to inspect it.
In his WC testimony Dougherty states - "...by the time I got to the sixth floor, they had found a gun..."
A really tall, unidentified TSBD employee is filmed on the 6th floor after the rifle's discovery.
What a crazy theory!


Or is it really sensible?
Obviously, my suspicion that Dougherty was the shooter is at odds with your MADS theory, so it's little wonder you're hostile to it.
Just like you were hostile with anyone who challenged your "Prayer Man" theory [or any other of your half-baked theories for that matter].
As such, any 'cririque' coming from your direction will be treated with the pinch of salt it deserves.

[Michael Welch]

Hi Alan and Dan, Back in 2013 when I saw this picture, I said stuff like it has to be Jack Edwin Dougherty because he could whip Billy Nolan Lovelady with one hand tied behind his back. Steve Logan chimed in and said that it was Billy and he was sure of it. Gary Mack wrote me and said that he has a crystal clear copy of the Alyea film, and it was definitely Lovelady. I disagreed with both of them, and I posted a picture from a FBI Mugshots page of a man with a policeman with a pencil behind I think his left ear, dressed in a white shirt that looked like Dougherty to me. I have searched for probably six months, and I cannot find this page with that picture anymore. Later on I think it was a man named Clyde Billington who out of the blue posted this Allen picture and said that it was Jack Dougherty on the West side behind the glass and Ochus Campbell in the doorway. I said that it probably was Jack but the man in the doorway is Otis Williams. Mr. Billington never responded or posted another post again. A couple of years later, I decided that it was Billy Lovelady. But today, I could go either way. Thank you for everything! Sincerely yours, Michael
 

[Dan O'meara]

Hi Alan and Dan, Back in 2013 when I saw this picture, I said stuff like it has to be Jack Edwin Dougherty because he could whip Billy Nolan Lovelady with one hand tied behind his back. Steve Logan chimed in and said that it was Billy and he was sure of it. Gary Mack wrote me and said that he has a crystal clear copy of the Alyea film, and it was definitely Lovelady. I disagreed with both of them, and I posted a picture from a FBI Mugshots page of a man with a policeman with a pencil behind I think his left ear, dressed in a white shirt that looked like Dougherty to me. I have searched for probably six months, and I cannot find this page with that picture anymore. Later on I think it was a man named Clyde Billington who out of the blue posted this Allen picture and said that it was Jack Dougherty on the West side behind the glass and Ochus Campbell in the doorway. I said that it probably was Jack but the man in the doorway is Otis Williams. Mr. Billington never responded or posted another post again. A couple of years later, I decided that it was Billy Lovelady. But today, I could go either way. Thank you for everything! Sincerely yours, Michael
 

I believe the man behind the window is this guy:



He is widely believed to be Robert Edwards, one of the eye-witnesses who testified that the man in the SN was wearing an open-necked white shirt - an item of clothing Oswald wasn't wearing that day and did not have in his possessions.

[Alan Ford]

The Fantastical Mr Ford rides in on his unicorn again.
Your "Multi-racial Assassination Death Squad Roaming Around the TSBD Building" theory [MADS for short] is the product of a truly fevered imagination.
Only to be outdone by your "Oswald Rolling Out a Banner" theory.
But none are as ridiculous as your "Prayer Man" theory.
What a joke that was. Glad to see you woke up from that nightmare but, oh, those wasted years.

Mr. DAN O'MEARA: You're not still doing the Lovelady-On-A-Box routine, are you?
Mr. DAN O'MEARA [a couple of days later]: This leaves two realistic choices - it is either Lovelady on a box [....]

 

[Michael Welch]

I believe the man behind the window is this guy:



He is widely believed to be Robert Edwards, one of the eye-witnesses who testified that the man in the SN was wearing an open-necked white shirt - an item of clothing Oswald wasn't wearing that day and did not have in his possessions.

Hi Dan, No, I do not think it is Robert Edwards behind the glass. However, you are definitely correct about Robert Edwards. Ronald Fischer is right behind him. What you and I need to do together is make a timeline of the Dealey Plaza events. Like the Allen picture you just posted would probably be around 1:00 pm. The one I posted would possibly be around 12:40pm. But in my opinion something needs to be done! Thank you as always for everything! Sincerely yours, Michael

[Dan O'meara]

Here's a side-by-side of the mystery man in Alyea and Lovelady, taken from the Martin film. It's the best match for their profiles I could make, both men at almost full profile.
As far as I'm concerned they are clearly two different people. The hairline of each man, particularly around the ear, are completely different, as is the shape of their heads.



The mystery man is dressed in casual clothing, certainly not that of a law enforcement officer. This means he can must surely be an unidentified TSBD employee.
He does not appear to be dressed as an office worker. He appears to be wearing a lighter coloured/white t-shirt under an off white, open-necked shirt. He is not wearing a tie.
This suggests he is one of "Truly's boys".
Under these circumstances he can only be Jack Dougherty.
Dougherty was around 6'2" tall when he was 18 years old, the mystery man is a noticeably tall person.
Dougherty testifies that by the time he reached the sixth floor the rifle had been found and the Alyea clip is taken on the sixth floor not long after the discovery of the rifle.

[Michael Welch]

Here's a side-by-side of the mystery man in Alyea and Lovelady, taken from the Martin film. It's the best match for their profiles I could make, both men at almost full profile.
As far as I'm concerned they are clearly two different people. The hairline of each man, particularly around the ear, are completely different, as is the shape of their heads.



The mystery man is dressed in casual clothing, certainly not that of a law enforcement officer. This means he can must surely be an unidentified TSBD employee.
He does not appear to be dressed as an office worker. He appears to be wearing a lighter coloured/white t-shirt under an off white, open-necked shirt. He is not wearing a tie.
This suggests he is one of "Truly's boys".
Under these circumstances he can only be Jack Dougherty.
Dougherty was around 6'2" tall when he was 18 years old, the mystery man is a noticeably tall person.
Dougherty testifies that by the time he reached the sixth floor the rifle had been found and the Alyea clip is taken on the sixth floor not long after the discovery of the rifle.

Hi Dan, I finally found the picture that I had been talking about. I cannot tell you anything about it. I just thought the man looked a lot like Jack and matched the man on the sixth floor. He has a pencil behind his right ear, just like Troy Eugene West! Thank you for everything! Sincerely yours, Michael