On The Trail Of Delusion

[John Iacoletti]

Why don't you drop the "fanciful Walt fabrication" and actually examine the evidence with an open mind?

I have.  All you have is an undated evidence list and a wild imagination.

[Walt Cakebread]

I have.  All you have is an undated evidence list and a wild imagination.

I don't consider my imagination to be "wild"....   I simply examine the evidence inventory lists and note that on 11/22/63 the DPD did not know much about the carcano that was found hidden beneath a pallet of books in the TSBD.  It is a fact that the DPD didn't know that it was commonly referred to as a "CARCANO".... So when they listed it on the evidence list they simply referred to it as ....quote-- Italian make 6.5 rifle---unquote  But when they used a photocopy of that original evidence list on 11/26/63 to produce an evidence inventory list they knew that the " Italian make 6.5mm rifle " was commonly called a Carcano carbine so they simply added that bit of information to the photocopy of the original evidence list from 11/22/63.

On 11/22/63, they  simply listed the the S&W revolver that was allegedly taken from LHO at the theater as;  quote--- 1  .38 cal pistol, 2" barrel --- unquote , but when they altered the photocopy of the original evidence inventory list from 11/22/63 they added a lot of information to that simple entry.

When they altered the original list that simply said  "1  .38 cal pistol, 2" barrel "---they added ....S&W, rev. sandblast finish , brown wooden handles, serial # 510210 , released to FBI Agent 11-22-63 and again on 11-26-63 

If you believe that commonsense reasoning is "wild imagination" then you apparently have no reasoning ability .....

[John Iacoletti]

Lots of people ("Oswald did it" evangelists included) consider their own unsubstantiated speculations to be "common sense reasoning".  Don't be like them.

[Walt Cakebread]

Lots of people ("Oswald did it" evangelists included) consider their own unsubstantiated speculations to be "common sense reasoning".  Don't be like them.

Can't you see that the original evidence list was compiled to accompany the photos of the evidence that was being released to the FBI at midnight as ordered by LBJ.  ( recall that LBJ told Curry that the FBI was taking charge of the investigation at midnight)

[John Iacoletti]

Can't you see that the original evidence list was compiled to accompany the photos of the evidence that was being released to the FBI at midnight as ordered by LBJ.  ( recall that LBJ told Curry that the FBI was taking charge of the investigation at midnight)

No, because there was no mention of the magic partial palmprint by Day or anybody else that night.

[Walt Cakebread]

No, because there was no mention of the magic partial palmprint by Day or anybody else that night.

there was no mention of the magic partial palmprint by Day or anybody else that night.

What does that prove??.... On the evening of 11/22/63,  Day never even attempted to pass off the smudge that he had lifted from the forestock of the rifle as a palm print.   He had spotted the smudge on the foregrip of the carcano while checking the rifle for prints just minutes after he lifted the rifle from the floor. He saw the smudge and simply lifted it for later examination at the Lab.  Tom Alyea said he watched Day lift a print from the foregrip and place the lift on an index card and scribble the pertinent information about that print on the index card.  The index card that was sent to the FBI at midnight is the same card that Tom Alyea saw day place the lift on.

[John Iacoletti]

there was no mention of the magic partial palmprint by Day or anybody else that night.

What does that prove??.... On the evening of 11/22/63,  Day never even attempted to pass off the smudge that he had lifted from the forestock of the rifle as a palm print.   He had spotted the smudge on the foregrip of the carcano while checking the rifle for prints just minutes after he lifted the rifle from the floor.

That's a story you just made up.

He saw the smudge and simply lifted it for later examination at the Lab.  Tom Alyea said he watched Day lift a print from the foregrip and place the lift on an index card and scribble the pertinent information about that print on the index card.

Alyea never said that.

  The index card that was sent to the FBI at midnight is the same card that Tom Alyea saw day place the lift on.

There is ZERO evidence that any index card was turned over at midnight on the 22nd/23rd.  The card showed up in Washington on the 29th.

[Fred Litwin]

https://www.onthetrailofdelusion.com/post/why-do-conspiracy-theorists-still-believe-julia-ann-mercer