Would you prefer that he deport all immigrants?
I should clarify my comments. I believe Democrats make arguments that are designed to influence people who think like they do. I believe that we should make arguments that may influence some MAGA people. By pointing out the obvious.
So, even if we ignore excellent arguments:
* Many immigrants are legal and should be allowed to stay.
* They greatly help the economy, not just increase the wealth of billionaires but ordinary Americans as will
* MAGA is influenced by racism, they just want as many non whites deported as possible
So let's pretend, for a moment, that mass deportations are good. Even with this assumption, it should be pointed out to MAGA people that Trump is highly unlikely to end up deporting the bulk of the immigrants, legal or illegal. Because their presence and labor helps the billionaires make more money. And they control Trump.
I think your typical MAGA person can see this, but hope against hope, against the all the evidence, notably the leisurely, at best deportation of immigrants, that Trump will do what he promised and what they hope for. The deportation of the bulk of the immigrants. This is a naive hope.