Are these two photos legit?

[Rick Plant]

Over the last several days I modeled CE510 in 3D to timestamp the image from information provided by faint shadows on the floor. The vertical window pane divider (muntin) of the western window casts a shadow intersecting a deep floor gouge-seen as white in CE510 from reflection of the flash. That deep gouge is still present in Sixth Floor Museum’s sniper’s nest exhibit. I was present last November 22 taking many photos trying time Alyea’s filming of the sniper’s rest boxes. Only by chance, I caught that muntin shadow at the same floor gouge at 13:17. 

Excellent work James!

[Bill Chapman]

Bill Chapman

And Garner had no good reason to be listening at all

[Richard Smith]

While heading down, he heard Truly/Baker coming up and ducked into the 2nd floor lunchroom. 

This statement would only be made by an imbecile....   

It's nothing but speculation and a wild imagination.... Rooted in a hatred for the vile villain presented by the police.

Let me ask ....  Mr "Smith"  If your scenario was true....and Lee heard foot steps on the stairs and assumed those sounds were from someone COMMING UP  the stairs ......HOW would Lee have known the sounds were the footsteps of a police officer??

Second question Mr idiot.....  Why would Lee have ducked into the lunchroom rather than fled through the office area??

What is with the endless personal insults?  Get a grip on yourself. 

[Richard Smith]

We know how and why Oswald got to the second floor.  He came down the stairs after assassinating JFK in an attempt to flee the building.  The stairs were the only means to do so.  While heading down, he heard Truly/Baker coming up and ducked into the 2nd floor lunchroom. 

100% speculation based on assumptions not supported by any evidence whatsoever.

While heading down, he heard Truly/Baker coming up and ducked into the 2nd floor lunchroom.

Pathetic. None of the people on the 5th and 4th floor hear anybody coming down the stairs and Truly and Baker don't hear anybody on those extremely noisy wooden steps either but Oswald hears Truly and Baker coming up.

Do you understand how infantile this "reasoning" is?

And still no answer from the contrarian brothers as to why anyone would be moving boxes around after the assassination.  Continued deflection.

[Walt Cakebread]

What is with the endless personal insults?  Get a grip on yourself.

Endless insults is right!.... Why do you continue to insult people with your utter nonsense ?.....Even a little kid would know that some of the stuff you present is utter rubbish.....and yet you apparently think we are all so stupid that we would believe your BS.   Now that's a real insult....

[James Hackerott]

Please take a look at the Powell and Dillard photos of the face of the TSBD ( they are posted in the thread " Are These Photos Legit"

The horizontal shadow being cast by the window above BRW head tells us which photo ( Dillard or Powell ) was taken first....

The table shows the sun position from 12:20-12:40. Azimuth changes almost 6 degrees over this short time span, while altitude changes very little. The animation simulates a view similar to Powell’s view. There is no noticeable change in the window shadow over this time period. I don’t know why there is an apparent difference between Dillard and Powell, but it is not due to sun position the best I can tell.

[Alan Ford]

JohnM

Word to the wise: Be wary of ALL Soopah-Doopah-Mytton-Gifs!



 

[Walt Cakebread]

Maybe Ten-Watt is using this scan of the Powell slide:



It has a lot of diffusion in the white areas, making the strip above Williams appear to be thicker. The windows and white trim on the shaded side of the building have a glow.

This one not so much glare in the white areas:



This Allen photo, taken after both Dillard and Powell, show little change in the window strip that was above Williams in the Dillard photo.

In this Powell photo it appears that Jarman and Norman have not yet joined BRW on the fifth floor.....This seems to confirm the shadow above BRW's head ....Powell took his photo BEFORE Dillard.