Geneva Hine

[John Mytton]

Nobody says the light went out

 

Geneva Hine said “the lights all went out”.

I can't argue with that, but we are still left with the problem of nobody besides Hine saying the lights went out and if you had any witness whatsoever to support the lights going out, you would scream it from the rooftops but alas the best you could do was insert Mooney into a post about Hine and hoped nobody would notice that both events were separated by time and space.

JohnM

[Richard Smith]

It's dishonest to suggest CTers are contending there was a power/phone outage simply because they "want to know what happened."  A thirst for knowledge!  That is laughable delusion.  The clear implication is that a power/phone outage was a result of and demonstrates the involvement of conspirators.  Like the bus ride to nowhere, these contrarians cannot articulate how this furthers any objective of their fantasy conspirators.  It just does.  However, if there is no claim being made that the alleged power/phone outage has any links to a conspiracy and was just coincidental, and it is just a "strawman" to suggest otherwise, then the issue of the alleged power/phone outages has no more importance than whether Oswald wore boxers or briefs that day. 

[John Iacoletti]

John was asking who, other than Hine, stated the lights all went out.
And your response is Geneva Hine.
Top work.

Wrong. “Mytton” claimed that “nobody said the lights went out”. And my response was that Hine did. Try to keep up.

[John Iacoletti]

I can't argue with that, but we are still left with the problem of nobody besides Hine saying the lights went out

So what? Hine is enough.

[John Iacoletti]

It's dishonest to suggest CTers are contending there was a power/phone outage simply because they "want to know what happened."

I never suggested anything about CTers, Strawman “Smith”. And cite me ever claiming the “involvement of conspirators” or STFU.

[John Iacoletti]

And if all the lights going out and the power being cut to the elevator are of “no importance”, why is the LN propaganda brigade working so hard to “explain” it with “what they could have meant” arguments?

[John Mytton]

Dillard snapped this photo shortly after the assassination,



The red arrows are pointing to lit fluro lights.



The office spaces on this floor that were photographed show fluro lights.







Whereas the storage space on this floor were at least partially illuminated with some sort of lamp.



Fluro's seem to light the majority of the ground floor.





When the fluros were photographed here from outside they are clearly visible.



JohnM

[Dan O'meara]

Wrong. “Mytton” claimed that “nobody said the lights went out”. And my response was that Hine did. Try to keep up.

Wrong.
John asked:

"...have you found any witnesses to corroborate your interpretation of Hine's words?"

Instead of answering you ask your own question:

"Have you found any witnesses to corroborate yours?"

So John answers your question - "Nobody says the lights wents out" - meaning there is no witness who supports your interpretation of Hine's words, there is no other witness who says "all the lights went out". (and he's right, there isn't)

Then John turns it back to you - "and now you" - meaning he's answered your question, now it's your turn to answer his question.

He then restates his question - "who corroborated your interpretation of Hine's words."

"Who corroborated your interpretation of Hine's words?" - and your answer is Geneva Hine.

Brilliant stuff