A Rock Solid Alibi.....

[John Iacoletti]

Perhaps they simply were not paying attention to what was going on near the elevators.

I’ve always wondered if West was sleeping at his desk or something, because he didn’t see or hear or remember anything.

[John Iacoletti]

Also, BRW could have not noticed someone hidden and being as quiet as a mouse in the sniper’s nest…

Not likely, since he was probably in the “sniper’s nest”. His lunch remains were originally seen there, and Rowland saw a black person in that window at about 12:15.

[Charles Collins]

I choose to not believe LHO’s obvious lie regarding where he was.

Please post that "obvious lie",  and the evidence that supports the lie....

The obvious lie is that he reportedly said he was in the domino room at the time the President passed the TSBD.

You then asked for “evidence that supports the lie”.  Other that what LHO reportedly said, I don’t know of any evidence that supports his lie. Why don’t you provide some. You are the one who claims the lie is a rock solid alibi.

[John Iacoletti]

I choose to not believe LHO’s obvious lie regarding where he was.

Please post that "obvious lie",  and the evidence that supports the lie....

It’s only an “obvious lie” because Charles already believes that Oswald shot Kennedy. It’s as circular an argument as “Richard’s” ridiculous “the best evidence that it could be done is that it was done”.

[Charles Collins]

BRW said he ate his lunch in the third aisle. And that is where his lunch remains were found and photographed.

[Walt Cakebread]

The obvious lie is that he reportedly said he was in the domino room at the time the President passed the TSBD.

You then asked for “evidence that supports the lie”.  Other that what LHO reportedly said, I don’t know of any evidence that supports his lie. Why don’t you provide some. You are the one who claims the lie is a rock solid alibi.

OMG!....How many times do you need to be told that Lee's claim that he was eating lunch ALONE in the Domino room when he saw "Junior" Jarman and Shorty Norman walk by.....  Jarman and Norman confirmed that they had in fact walked by the lunchroom while on their way to the fifth floor.   They said they left the front of the TSBD at 12:25 and arrived on the 5th floor at 12:28. Therfore they would have walked by the lunchroom at about 12:27.

There.... I've provided the evidence that Lee was in the lunchroom .... Now you need to provide the evidence that he was on the sixth floor at 12:30......   And saying that Lee was a liar is just your opinion...... So provide something that proves that he lied...   

[Jerry Freeman]

My point is that in order for this so called “rock solid alibi” to be feasible, LHO would have had to walk across the first floor in plain view of the two others who said that they were on the first floor at that point in time. Neither one of them saw him ------Charles Collins

... there was no plain view. All anyone needs to do is look at the evidence photos of the 1st floor to know that. 

The "plain view" comment is definitely a wiggle it in my way argument [just like the invisible train in the Patrolman White thread]
Of course cops never lie huh?
I would like to see a link to these evidence photographs that were taken on the first floor.

Another issue is a man seen at the 'sniper window' minutes after the shooting.
Report from Ms Lillian Mooneyham CE 2098----
https://www.history-matters.com/archive/jfk/wc/wcvols/wh24/pdf/WH24_CE_2098.pdf

[Charles Collins]

OMG!....How many times do you need to be told that Lee's claim that he was eating lunch ALONE in the Domino room when he saw "Junior" Jarman and Shorty Norman walk by.....  Jarman and Norman confirmed that they had in fact walked by the lunchroom while on their way to the fifth floor.   They said they left the front of the TSBD at 12:25 and arrived on the 5th floor at 12:28. Therfore they would have walked by the lunchroom at about 12:27.

There.... I've provided the evidence that Lee was in the lunchroom .... Now you need to provide the evidence that he was on the sixth floor at 12:30......   And saying that Lee was a liar is just your opinion...... So provide something that proves that he lied...   

So,

1.) LHO said that he was in the domino room.

2.) LHO said that he saw some others walk in.

That’s it?   


I asked for evidence other than what LHO reportedly said. Apparently you have none?