Oswald: No power lunch

[Martin Weidmann]

calm down and let's have a civilized conversation.

   Yer joking ...    I don't believe it's possible to have a rational conversation with you Mr. M.    You don't even recognize that Bill Whaley said that his passenger was wearing a BLUE JACKET and BLUE trousers.  ...And that most certainly was NOT Lee Oswald.

I don't believe it's possible to have a rational conversation with you Mr. M. 

Indeed

[John Mytton]

I have stood at the window next to the sniper's nest and looked down.

Have you got a photo? So you were only standing at the window but according to Brennan, Oswald was sitting on the window sill, which would have placed him much closer to Elm street and allowed a much better view of what was below. And from Oswald's position sitting on the window sill with only a slight lean, Oswald could have seen directly below just like you said above, "unless that person's torso was hanging out of the window"



JohnM

[Alan Ford]

How did Mr Oswald know no one else had been in the Domino Room at 12:26? Could he see in there from the sixth floor?

[Martin Weidmann]

Have you got a photo? So you were only standing at the window but according to Brennan, Oswald was sitting on the window sill, which would have placed him much closer to Elm street and allowed a much better view of what was below. And from Oswald's position sitting on the window sill with only a slight lean, Oswald could have seen directly below just like you said above, "unless that person's torso was hanging out of the window"



JohnM

Still desperately trying to avoid answering my question? Why am I not surprised?


And from Oswald's position sitting on the window sill with only a slight lean, Oswald could have seen directly below just like you said above, "unless that person's torso was hanging out of the window"

A slight lean? You clearly have never been there. Brennan was sitting on a wall two streets away from the TSBD.
Norman and Jarman were on the sidewalk next to the TSBD. It doesn't take a genius to work out the difference, which is probably why you seem to be struggling. If Norman and Jarman were right in front of the TSBD, there is no way anybody could have seen them from the 6th floor window. But even if they could have been seen, it would be insignificant, unless you're trying to concoct a story about Oswald guessing about their subsequent actions and actually getting it right.

If that's what you are trying to say, why do you hesitate to answer my question?

[John Mytton]

calm down and let's have a civilized conversation.

   Yer joking ...    I don't believe it's possible to have a rational conversation with you Mr. M.    You don't even recognize that Bill Whaley said that his passenger was wearing a BLUE JACKET and BLUE trousers.  ...And that most certainly was NOT Lee Oswald.

Right on queue, whenever your team mates are struggling out you pop to give your 2 cents, and this time with an attempted diversion, nice.

JohnM

[John Mytton]

A slight lean? You clearly have never been there.

Even if you were there, the photo I posted shows you could never get even close to see what Oswald could see. Try again and repeating that you were there doesn't prove your speculation.



JohnM

[Bill Chapman]

Right on queue, whenever your team mates are struggling out you pop to give your 2 cents, and this time with an attempted diversion, nice.

JohnM

If I say 'a penny for your thoughts' and you put your two-cents worth in, who gets the extra penny? -Steven Wright

[Martin Weidmann]

Even if you were there, the photo I posted shows you could never get even close to see what Oswald could see. Try again and repeating that you were there doesn't prove your speculation.



JohnM

Stop behaving as an idiot. The one speculating based on a worthless photo that proves nothing is you. But hey, what else is new?

I was at the window next to the sealed of area of the snipers nest. If anything there would have been a better view of what/who was on the sidewalk beneath the s/n window and even from there I couldn't see the sidewalk.  So your photo only shows you have a vivid imagination and and pretty nosensical narrative to defend about Oswald seeing Jarman and Norman right beneath him and guessing they went to the back of the building together, entered through the back door and walked towards the elevators (which is exactly what they did).

When you have to bend the facts and the truth to tell a false story, you've already lost the argument. You should know this by now. You been destroyed so many times before and still you do not learn..... Which is exactly why Walt is correct.